Blog

Selecting the appropriate lumber for your woodworking projects is a pivotal step that can significantly influence the quality and durability of your creations. Given that lumber represents a notable investment, gaining a thorough understanding of your options prior to heading to the lumber yard is essential. At times, choosing a more affordable wood species may serve the same function as a more expensive counterpart. Every type of wood possesses unique traits that affect its workability, visual appeal, and longevity. Recognizing these characteristics can be the difference between a cherished item and a regretted project. Both hardwoods and softwoods are available in an array of industry grades based on the percentage of clear (knot-free) wood present in each board.

Woodworking Insights

A skilled woodworker from Vermont recently shared a story about creating a unique dining table for a family heirloom project. The tabletop was crafted from gorgeous reclaimed oak, chosen for its rich history and rustic charm. To enhance the piece, he decided to use a contrasting wood for the legs and apron, opting for softwood spruce due to its lighter color and availability. While the design initially appeared promising, over time, the spruce proved unable to withstand the weight and wear of daily use. Small dents and structural issues began to emerge, overshadowing the beauty of the oak top. This experience highlights an essential principle in woodworking: material selection is not just about aesthetics but also about function. Understanding the strengths and limitations of different wood species ensures that your projects are not only beautiful but also durable and fit for purpose.

Choosing the Right Lumber

When it comes to sourcing lumber, several key factors need evaluation, including the types of wood on offer, the appropriate grade of lumber for your project's requirements, and whether the boards you choose are planed or left rough-sawn. Thoughtful consideration of these factors can lead to cost savings and an enhancement in the overall quality of your finished piece. Expertise in selecting lumber often arises from practical experience. Working with different wood species and grades allows you to develop a deeper understanding of which materials work best for your intended use. This guide serves as a solid foundation, arming you with vital knowledge for making informed decisions. You will discover the distinctions between hardwoods and softwoods, gain insights into sheet goods, understand how wood responds to moisture, and learn about various milling and grading systems. Additionally, you will receive pragmatic shopping advice to help you approach the lumberyard with confidence—ultimately leading to better-informed choices and potential savings!

Structure of a Tree: Understanding Wood Anatomy

Each tree contains a central area called the pith, surrounded by numerous annual growth rings that offer structural support, even in their dead state. The heartwood—often celebrated by artisans for its consistency and character—is encircled by the sapwood, which serves as a conduit for transporting moisture and nutrients. The cambium layer, situated at the outer ring of sapwood, is vital for new growth, adding layers of sapwood annually. Beneath the protective bark lies the phloem, which transports nutrients back to the roots. Most lumber mills remove the outer layers (including bark, phloem, cambium, and sapwood) when converting logs into boards. Often, the discarded materials find second lives as mulch, paper, or fuel. Occasionally, you’ll find lumber featuring sapwood at your local yard; in woods like walnut and cherry, this lighter band runs along one edge. If incorporated into a project, sapwood can become more noticeable after finishing unless it’s stained to match the rest of the piece. This trait is one reason why sapwood is typically avoided in furniture-making.

Forest Management Insights

Softwoods, or coniferous trees, generally grow at a quicker pace than hardwoods, which affects supply, demand, and pricing for both lumber types. Their rapid growth allows patterns for replanting and harvesting, sometimes within 15 years, while hardwoods often take a minimum of 75 years to mature. This quicker turnaround helps maintain a steady supply of softwood at lower costs, benefiting both construction and woodworking. Softwood trees reproduce using substantial cones rather than flowers or fruit, causing seeds to descend in proximity to the parent tree and promoting dense growth. Lumber mills utilize this phenomenon to cultivate conifers closely together, resulting in long, straight logs.

Distinguishing Hardwoods from Softwoods

In botanical terms, trees are categorized into hardwoods and softwoods. A straightforward way to tell them apart is that hardwoods are deciduous, shedding their leaves each fall and reproducing through flowers or seeds. Conversely, softwoods retain their needle-like leaves throughout winter and disperse seeds via open cones. The distinction between "hardwood" and "softwood" doesn’t correlate with the actual hardness of the wood—some hardwoods can be softer than softwoods! All trees experience two distinct growth spurts yearly. The spring yield produces lighter-colored earlywood, while late summer and autumn generate the denser latewood, forming the darker tree rings often counted for age. Softwood trees tend to exhibit broader earlywood bands due to their faster growth rate, resulting in larger, less dense cells that make them easier to work with.

Color, Figure & Grain Patterns

Craftsmanship in woodworking heavily revolves around selecting pieces featuring distinct colors, figures, and grain patterns. The coloration of wood stems from the reactions of its natural compounds—like tannins and resins—when exposed to oxygen; as time elapses, the wood darkens and develops a beautiful patina. Grain patterns vary based on the orientation of wood fibers and the cutting method applied during milling.

Hardwoods vs. Softwoods: More than Just Terminology

Despite the implications of their names, the distinction between hardwoods and softwoods is predicated on leaf types. For instance, oak is a classic hardwood with broad leaves, while pine is a coniferous softwood retaining its needles year-round. This explains why it’s easier to drive a nail into wider-pored pine compared to tightly-grained oak, which possesses a more condensed cellular structure that resists penetration. Interesting about hardwood trees is their ability to grow branches in multiple directions to maximize sunlight absorption. However, this characteristic can lead to striking figures and grain patterns—albeit at times woodworking with highly figured woods may involve more challenges due to their susceptibility to warping. Historically, furniture makers utilized vast virgin forests full of conifers, with wide white pine boards readily available. Nowadays, reforested pine yields narrower boards often riddled with knots and excess sapwood. Modern softwoods typically suit framing, sheathing, and construction applications.

Lumber Cuts: How Wood is Processed

Lumber mills employ various cutting techniques influenced by the intended use and quality of logs, with the most utilized methods being plain sawing and quartersawing. Plain sawing, also known as flat sawing, entails rotating the log to optimize yield and bypass the central pith. This method generates the most economically feasible lumber, fitting for both construction and custom woodworking. However, cuts are made tangentially to growth rings, often leading to more distortion than quartersawn alternatives.

Quartersawing involves cutting the log lengthwise before slicing it into wedges—yielding boards with perpendicular growth rings to the board faces. Though quartersawing produces less yield, it results in dimensionally stable lumber with tight, straight grain—a desirable feature for specific hardwoods.

Drying Methods for Lumber

Upon cutting logs, lumber is classified as "green," retaining high moisture levels unsuitable for most uses until appropriately dried. Two primary drying methods exist: air drying and kiln drying. Air drying stacks the wood with stickers inserted between boards to promote airflow, leaving piles exposed to the elements for extended periods (sometimes years) until moisture dissipates. Variations may include covering the top layer with plastic or canvas while periodically adjusting settings to optimize moisture control. Kiln drying occurs in controlled environments using gas, electric, or solar-powered ovens. While more expensive to operate, kilns deliver a uniform drying experience. Lumber dried in kilns is widely available at lumberyards due to the expedited process. The American Lumber Standards Committee categorizes lumber based on moisture content: "green" lumber contains 20% or more, while "dry" lumber holds 19% or less.

Monitoring Moisture & Wood Movement

Whatever drying method is applied, wood boards aim to achieve equilibrium moisture content (EMC), adapting by absorbing or releasing moisture relative to their environment. Kiln-dried lumber won’t regain the moisture levels it had while green, but will still undergo expansion or contraction. Moisture content in lumber typically ranges from 6% to over 20%. Framing lumber should ideally remain below 18% moisture (with around 14% being optimal), while furniture stock should hover between 6% and 8%. Accurate moisture readings can largely be obtained with a moisture meter—a reliable electronic tool that checks moisture levels at fresh-cut surfaces. Most reputable hardwood suppliers allow borrowing or provide readings when requested.

Evaluating Wood Movement

Wood predominantly expands and contracts along the grain, exhibiting approximately double the tangential movement compared to radial. In standard plain-sawn boards, the most significant expansion or contraction typically affects width and thickness, with moisture levels being more impactful on "greener" wood.

Recognizing Lumber Distortion & Defects

Lumber may warp or distort during drying, resulting in four common distortion types: cupping (where long edges arch inward), crooking (side-to-side warping), bowing (lengthwise curving), and twisting (ends turning in opposing directions). Addressing cupping might involve cutting the board into narrower segments and reglueing after they settle. Crooking can often be rectified with straightforward machining. Addressing bowing and twisting presents greater complications, requiring specific techniques to mitigate over time. As you look for lumber, closely inspect each piece for distortions; a quick glance along the board's edges can reveal valuable insights about its state. Defects like pitch pockets, spalling, or loose knots are generally recognizable, allowing you to salvage the wood by cutting away the problematic areas.

However, case hardening—when the outer layers dry quickly while the interior retains moisture—could remain hidden until the board is cut. Indicators include checks (small cracks) and shakes (larger cracks radiating from the center). Honeycombing occurs when weak internal structures manifest as tiny voids, the result of uneven drying. It’s wise to steer clear of boards exhibiting signs of case hardening, as this defect can lead to severe structural challenges over time.

Understanding Softwood Lumber Sizes

In the U.S., softwood lumber is classified according to strict industry standards, which consider strength, appearance, and moisture content. Each board bears a stamp indicating its grade, species, and seasoning state (dry or green). The nominal sizes (like 1x4 or 2x4) do not reflect the actual dimensions of the lumber post-surfacing. For instance, a 1x4 measures closer to 3/4” x 3 1/2” after milling. Similarly, softwoods categorized as framing stock carry a 2” nominal thickness, recognized as dimension lumber.

Common Softwood Lumber Grades

Understanding Various Types of Wood: Hardwood Lumber Sizes

When seeking hardwood, you may encounter nominal dimensions akin to softwoods, though some suppliers follow similar standards for hardwood boards. At your local home improvement center, expect to find an assortment of hardwood species, including oak, maple, and cherry. These boards usually measure 3/4 inch in thickness, have flat edges, and come in standardized widths and lengths. Within the lumber industry, this preparatory processing is classified as "S4S," which denotes Surfaced Four Sides—although it carries a higher price at the mill, this choice often benefits those lacking a thickness planer or jointer for finishing. If specialty hardwoods or thicker variations interest you, consider visiting a traditional lumberyard, which typically features a diverse selection of hardwoods offered in random widths and varying thicknesses (see below for more on Hardwood Lumber Grades). You’ll also discover S2S (planed smooth on two faces with rough edges) and roughsawn boards, which are cut directly from logs, dried, and sold to yards. Hardwoods serve numerous roles, leading to a broader range of thickness options compared to standard lumber. As a result, the quartering system has been developed for measuring lumber thickness, enabling you to purchase hardwoods in increments of 1/4 inch starting at 1 inch and up. Most suppliers list common hardwood varieties available in thicknesses of three through twelve quarters (3/4 to 3 inches).

Understanding Hardwood Lumber Grades

Unlike the grading system for softwoods, hardwood lumber is categorized based on different criteria. Grades are determined by the percentage of clear face cuts obtainable around a board's defects—such as knots, splits, and pitch pockets. Higher grades denote more clear cuts and fewer defects:

• FAS (Firsts and Seconds): 83% or better for clear cuts
• Select: 83%
• No. 1 Common: 66%
• No. 2A & 2B Common: 50%
• No. 3A Common: 33%
• No. 3B Common: 25%

When selecting hardwood, choose a grade that meets your project's requirements while staying within budget—often a lower Common grade can suffice, allowing you to save money while still obtaining quality lumber.

Hardwood Surfacing Options

For those who engage in projects sporadically, purchasing S4S boards is practical, as they arrive planed on both sides with flat edges, ready for milling. Alternatively, if you have access to a jointer, you could opt for S2S lumber that retains rough edges but has the faces smoothed. The most cost-effective option remains roughsawn lumber, which requires you to complete all surface preparation. Occasionally, lumberyards will offer to plane your stock for a nominal fee if you lack a planer.

Calculating Board Feet

A majority of lumberyards price hardwoods by board foot, which can lead to confusion regarding how much lumber you truly need. The three boards below may all equal 2 board feet, yet their dimensions may be completely different. A board foot is defined as a piece of lumber measuring 1 inch thick by 12 inches wide by 12 inches long, or any combination that results in 144 cubic inches. To determine the total board feet in a lumber piece, apply the formula: Thickness (in inches) × Width (in inches) × Length (in inches) ÷ 144. If it's easier to calculate one dimension in feet, divide by 12 instead. Remember to include a buffer for waste in your estimates. Professionals often recommend budgeting an additional 30% for S2S stock and around 40% for roughsawn, primarily due to hidden defects surfacing after planing.

Shopping for Lumber

When you're ready to acquire hardwood, understanding your options is paramount. Large home improvement stores primarily carry softwood framing lumber, with limited selections of hardwood species, often compromising quality. While these stores may provide competitive pricing, their inventory and caliber typically can’t compete with specialty lumberyards that feature a broader selection of milling choices and decorative wood panels.

For those seeking premium hardwoods and veneered sheets, specialty yards serve as excellent resources often found in metropolitan areas, catering mainly to commercial woodworkers and professional furniture makers. While the staff here are knowledgeable enough to assist seasoned clients, they can also dedicate time to helping enthusiastic learners understand finer points of the trade. Although most available lumber falls into S2S or rough-sawn categories, being equipped with a jointer or planer is prudent for self-preparation.

The Appeal of Reclaimed Lumber

In recent years, reclaimed lumber has surged in popularity due to its sustainable nature and distinctive character. Much of this wood originates from old structures, with some even retrieved from depths of the Great Lakes. Since this lumber comes from ancient forests, it often features exceptional straightness and stability alongside striking grain patterns, thanks to its long seasoning. Although reclaimed wood is an excellent choice, don’t overlook the potential of repurposing materials from renovation projects or old furniture by reusing those materials in your woodworking tasks. At times, a bit of sanding or resurfacing might rejuvenate them! Do ensure to screen reclaimed materials for hidden metal fasteners that can pose risks during machining. You might also discover diamond-in-the-rough boards at local sawmills, typically available at more economical prices than standard lumber yards. Be aware, however, that true colors and patterns may only reveal themselves post-planing with rough-sawn materials.

Best Practices for Buying Lumber

Ultimately, whether you choose to buy from a big-box retailer, specialty yard, contractor supply, or online, be sure to keep these essential tips in mind while buying hardwood:

• Craft a Thoughtful Shopping List: Formulate a list based on your understanding of common lumber sizes and grades. It’s beneficial to make a preliminary visit to gauge availability before making the trip.
• Consider Alternative Woods: Utilize less expensive woods, like poplar or pine, in less noticeable areas of your projects. Many woodworkers have successfully utilized "secondary" woods while saving the premium materials for visible components, such as tabletops and fronts.
• Account for Waste: When estimating your lumber needs as a beginner, consider factoring in up to 30% for waste. Over time, you'll refine your estimates, but it's wise to keep receipts for any unused lumber that can be returned.
• Explore Mail-Order Options: In cases where specific species are scarce, consider ordering lumber through the mail. Many woodworking publications list suppliers with competitive pricing, but checking quality before making large purchases is crucial.
• Comparison Shop: After identifying your lumber needs, compare prices across suppliers. You might find discounts on slightly damaged items or during inventory sales.
• Plan for Transport: Contemplate how you'll move larger materials, particularly sheet goods, from the yard. Taking advantage of delivery services provided by select suppliers can spare you the hassle of dealing with oversized materials in your vehicle.

Conclusion

Exploring the world of hardwoods unveils a rich variety of options, each with unique characteristics and applications. By equipping yourself with knowledge about the various types of wood, their respective grades, and optimal purchasing strategies, you pave the way for woodworking projects that not only meet functional requirements but also showcase creativity and craftsmanship. If you're interested in delving deeper into custom woodworking, don't forget to check out Willy's Woods. With the right insights and resources at your disposal, your woodworking adventure can flourish into a fulfilling and enjoyable pursuit.